Elon Musk will have to go on trial after accusing a British diver who helped rescue the Thai boys trapped in a cave last year of being a paedophile.
The billionaire Tesla boss had tried to have the defamation lawsuit filed by the diver, Vernon Unsworth, dismissed but a federal judge in Los Angeles has ruled the case must proceed in October.
The spat began in July last year when Mr Unsworth, an experienced cave diver who divides his time between Thailand and Britain, dismissed Mr Musk’s own efforts to assist the cave rescue as a “PR stunt” in a TV interview.
From
15p
€0.18
$0.18
USD 0.27
a day, more exclusives, analysis and extras.
The eccentric businessman had personally brought a miniature submarine to Thailand which he hoped could reach the stranded youth football team inside the cave complex. In the end, the submarine was never used.
“He can stick his submarine where it hurts,” Mr Unsworth told CNN. “It just had absolutely no chance of working. He had no conception of what the cave passage was like. It was just a PR stunt.”
The 12 boys and their coach in the cave
REUTERS
A rescue team stands in the entrance to the cave
AP
A relative shows a picture of the boys after they were found on 2 July
AFP/Getty
Thai military inside the cave complex
EPA
The 12 boys and their soccer coach who were rescued from a flooded cave arrive for a news conference in the northern province of Chiang Rai, Thailand,
REUTERS
The boys and their soccer coach rescued from a flooded cave play soccer
REUTERS
The young footballers and their coach appeared healthy when they appeared before the media for the first time since the rescue
AFP/Getty Images
EPA
Coach Ekapol Chantawong
REUTERS
The 12 rescued members of the Wild Boar soccer team are greeted by their classmates on a mini soccer pitch
EPA
Rescued Thai football coach Ekkapol Chantawong together with 12 children pays tribute to Thai navy diver, Samarn Kunan, who died whilst attempting to rescue the boys
AFP/Getty Images
Twelve young footballers and their coach rescued from a Thai caves being treated in hospital
EPA
Rescued soccer team members posing with a sketch of the Thai Navy SEAL diver who died while trying to rescue them
AP
Players writing messages on a drawing of former Navy SEAL diver Saman Kunan who died during attempts to rescue them
AFP/Getty Images
Rescued “Wild Boars” football team members (top row L to R) Adul Sam-on, 14, Ekkarat Wongsukchan, 14, Phipat Photi, 15, Chanin Wiboonrungrueang, 11, (middle row L to R) Pornchai Khamluang, 16, Duangphet Promthep, 13, Peerapat Sompiengjai, 16, Sompong Jaiwong, 13, (bottom row L to R) Mongkol Boonpiem, 13, Prachak Sutham, 14, Nutthawut Thakamsong, 14, and Phanumas Saengdee, 13, recovering at the hospital in Chiang Rai province
AFP/Getty Images
AFP/Getty Images
The life vest belonging to Duangpetch Promthep, the rescued captain of the “Wild Boars”,
REUTERS
Divers from the rescue mission, from left to right: Chris Jewell, Mike Clayton, Rick Stanton, Lance-corporal Connor Rae, Josh Bratchley, Gary Mitchell and Jim Way who helped to save 12 schoolboys and their football coach from a flooded cave in Thailand, speak to media after arriving back at London’s Heathrow Airport
PA
Volunteers gather for a ceremony before the clean up operation at the Tham Luang cave
AFP/Getty Images
The last four Thai Navy SEALs come out safely after completing the rescue mission inside a cave where 12 boys and their soccer coach have been trapped since June 23, in Mae Sai, Chiang Rai province, northern Thailand. Thailand’s navy SEALs say all 12 boys and their soccer coach have been rescued from a flooded cave in far northern Thailand, ending an ordeal that lasted more than two weeks.
Royal Thai Navy/AP
People celebrate
AP
A woman lifts her child near the hospital, seen at left, as ambulance transporting members of the children’s football team arrives
AFP/Getty Images
Volunteers react after hearing all boys were rescued
REUTERS
REUTERS
Getty Images
Rescue personnel work at the Tham Luang cave
REUTERS
Rescue personnel work at the Tham Luang cave
REUTERS
REUTERS
Onlookers at the junction in front of Chiangrai Prachanukroh Hospital watch and cheer
Getty Images
Journalists celebrate after a news conferenc
REUTERS
An ambulance, reportedly carrying members of the rescued football team, arrives at a hospital
AFP/Getty Images
Thai Navy divers in the Tham Luang cave
Thai Navy SEAL via Getty Images
Rescue personnel work at the Tham Luang cave
REUTERS
Thai media listen Chiang Rai province acting Gov. Narongsak Osatanakorn
AP
Police and military personnel use umbrellas to cover a stretcher near a helicopter and an ambulance at a military airport in Chiang Rai as rescue operations continue for those still trapped inside the cave in Khun Nam Nang Non Forest Park in the Mae Sai district. Four boys among the group of 13 trapped in a flooded Thai cave for more than a fortnight were rescued on July 8 after surviving a treacherous escape, raising hopes elite divers would also save the others soon
AFP/Getty
Thai military medical personnel walking inside a restricted area as preparations are made to transport rescued boys from Tham Luang cave to a hospital
EPA
Thai authorities placing a rescued boy in an ambulance
EPA/Chiang Rai
Paramedics, believed to be carrying a boy who has been evacuated after being trapped inside a flooded cave, approach a helicopter in Chiang Rai
Chiang Rai Tourist Police via Reuters
This frame grab from video tweeted by Elon Musk shows a “tiny kid-sized submarine” being tested in a pool at Palisades Charter High School, in California. Musk’s Space X rocket company tested the submarine that could potentially help rescue the remaining children and their coach trapped in a flooded cave in Thailand.
Elon Musk via AP
Thai military personnel preparing to move the boys to a hospital
EPA
Emergency workers carrying one of the boys rescued from the cave
EPA/Chiang Rai
A Thai nurse walks past an ambulance at a covered area of the Chiangrai Prachanukroh Hospital
EPA
Indian schoolchildren hold placards and pictures during a prayer event for the safe rescue of young football players and their coach
AFP/Getty Images
An ambulance exits from the Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty Images
A military helicopter carrying rescued schoolboys approaches to land at a military airport in Chiang Rai.
REUTERS
A group of volunteers prepare to leave in search of alternative entry points to the Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty
Thai soldiers drag a water pipe to bypass water from the mountain and to not get back inside the cave
AP
Hundreds of rescuers with equipment continue the rescue operation
Getty
Monks lead out family members of the boys from the cave site after a morning prayer
Getty
Thai rescue workers take a break
AFP/Getty
Water pumps push water out of the cave
Getty
Relatives, of the 12 schoolboys and their soccer coach trapped inside a flooded cave in the Tham Luang cave complex cook, for rescue workers and volunteers near the cave complex
REUTERS
Rescue teams carry water pipes to the entrance of cave complex
AP
Thai soldiers and police officers are seen as rescue operations continue for the 12 boys and their football team coach trapped in Tham Luang cave at Khun Nam Nang Non Forest Park in the Mae Sai district of Chiang Rai province on July 7, 2018. More than 100 chimneys are being drilled into the mountainside in a frantic bid to reach a Thai youth football team trapped in a cave complex below, the head of the rescue mission said on July 7
AFP/Getty
Family members pray in front of a Buddhist statue near a cave where 12 boys and their soccer coach have been trapped since June 23, in Mae Sai, Chiang Rai province, in northern Thailand Saturday, July 7, 2018. The soccer coach trapped in a cave with 12 Thai boys apologized to their parents in the first letter he and the team have sent out through divers, in which the boys say they’re doing well and missing their families
AP
Thai military inside the cave complex
EPA
Australian Federal Police and Defense Force personnel talk with a Thai diver
AP
A rescuer prepares a light for diving to reach the 12 boys and their soccer coach
AP
Soliders are seen near the Tham Luang cave complex, where 12 schoolboys and their soccer coach are trapped inside a flooded cave, in the northern province of Chiang Rai, Thailand
REUTERS
Water is pumped from a flooded cave
AP
Thai rescuers rest during the ongoing rescue operation
EPA
Thai military personnel inside a cave complex
EPA
Rescue teams assemble at the entrance to the Tham Luang cave complex
AP
Thai Navy soldiers in the flooded Tham Luang cave during rescue operations
AFP/Getty
Local Thai National Park Rescuers relax at base camp
Getty Images
Journalists work near Tham Luang cave complex
REUTERS
A Thai policeman guards an area under rainfall
AFP/Getty Images
A Thai policeman guards an area under rainfall near the Tham Luang cave
AFP/Getty Images
Divers gather before they enter to the Tham Luang cave, where 12 boys and their soccer coach are trapped, in the northern province of Chiang Rai, Thailand
REUTERS
Thai military bring water pumps to the cave. Videos released by the Thai Navy SEAL shows that the boys, aged 11 to 16, and their 25-year-old coach are in good health in Tham Luang Nang Non cave and the challenge now will be to extract the party safely.
Getty Images
An honour guard holds up a picture of Samarn Kunan, 38, a former member of Thailand’s elite navy SEAL unit who died working to save 12 boys and their soccer coach trapped inside a flooded cave, at an airport in Rayong province
Reuters
Military personnel are seen in front of the Tham Luang cave
REUTERS
The former navy SEAL diver, Saman Kunan, who died trying to help save the trapped boys
Saman Kunan/Facebook
Rescue workers convene behind a large pile of oxygen tanks
AFP/Getty Images
A Buddhist monk leads military honor guards carrying a flag-draped coffin containing former Thai Navy Seal Petty Officer 1st class Saman Kunan, who died in the ongoing Tham Luang cave rescue operations, during a repatriation ceremony at Mae Fah Luang international airport.
EPA
Thai students pray for the ongoing rescue operations
EPA
Thai soldiers and police officers pay their respects as a Thai Navy plane carrying the body of Saman Kunan takes off
AFP/Getty Images
Rescue workers prepare frogsuits for soldiers
AFP/Getty Images
The diver’s death raises serious doubts over the safety of attempting to bring the 12 boys and their football coach out through the cramped, waterlogged passageways of the Tham Luang cave.
AP
Family members pray before a shrine in Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty Images
A family member prays before a shrine in Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty Images
Thai rescue teams use headlamps to enter a pitch-black cave complex where 12 boys and their soccer coach went missing, in Mae Sai, Chiang Rai province, northern Thailand, Monday, July 2, 2018. The group was discovered late July 2 after 10 days totally cut off from the outside world, and while they are for the most physically healthy, experts say the ordeal has likely taken a mental toll that could worsen the longer the situation lasts.
AP
The mother of a trapped child reacts during the ongoing rescue operations
EPA
Family members pray before a shrine in Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty Images
Grandmother Kham-aoey Promthep, 64, shows a photograph of her grandson, Duangpetch Promthep, who is one of 13 members
EPA
A Thai student shows an image of her classmate Panumas Sangdee, who is one of 13 members of a soccer team trapped
EPA
Buddhist monk Kruba Boonchum visits the site to perform religious rituals
Getty Images
Thai Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha visits the site
REUTERS
British cave-divers (from left to right) Richard William Stanton, Robert Charles Harper and John Volanthen join the rescue effort
AFP/Getty Images
Divers prepare for the rescue mission
EPA
A rescuer enters the cave
AP
The father of one of the missing boys thanks soldiers after the boys are found
AFP/Getty Images
Relatives celebrate after they hear that the boys have been found
AFP/Getty Images
Relatives pray after they hear that the boys have been found
Getty Images
Relatives celebrate after they hear that the boys have been found
AFP/Getty Images
General Bancha Duriyaphan announces the news to the press
Getty Images
With the rescue mission still ongoing, Thai soldiers carry equipment into the cave
EPA
With the rescue mission still ongoing, Thai soldiers carry equipment into the cave
EPA
Water is being pumped out of the flooded cave complex in an effort to make the rescue easier
Getty Images
The 12 boys and their coach in the cave
REUTERS
A rescue team stands in the entrance to the cave
AP
A relative shows a picture of the boys after they were found on 2 July
AFP/Getty
Thai military inside the cave complex
EPA
The 12 boys and their soccer coach who were rescued from a flooded cave arrive for a news conference in the northern province of Chiang Rai, Thailand,
REUTERS
The boys and their soccer coach rescued from a flooded cave play soccer
REUTERS
The young footballers and their coach appeared healthy when they appeared before the media for the first time since the rescue
AFP/Getty Images
EPA
Coach Ekapol Chantawong
REUTERS
The 12 rescued members of the Wild Boar soccer team are greeted by their classmates on a mini soccer pitch
EPA
Rescued Thai football coach Ekkapol Chantawong together with 12 children pays tribute to Thai navy diver, Samarn Kunan, who died whilst attempting to rescue the boys
AFP/Getty Images
Twelve young footballers and their coach rescued from a Thai caves being treated in hospital
EPA
Rescued soccer team members posing with a sketch of the Thai Navy SEAL diver who died while trying to rescue them
AP
Players writing messages on a drawing of former Navy SEAL diver Saman Kunan who died during attempts to rescue them
AFP/Getty Images
Rescued “Wild Boars” football team members (top row L to R) Adul Sam-on, 14, Ekkarat Wongsukchan, 14, Phipat Photi, 15, Chanin Wiboonrungrueang, 11, (middle row L to R) Pornchai Khamluang, 16, Duangphet Promthep, 13, Peerapat Sompiengjai, 16, Sompong Jaiwong, 13, (bottom row L to R) Mongkol Boonpiem, 13, Prachak Sutham, 14, Nutthawut Thakamsong, 14, and Phanumas Saengdee, 13, recovering at the hospital in Chiang Rai province
AFP/Getty Images
AFP/Getty Images
The life vest belonging to Duangpetch Promthep, the rescued captain of the “Wild Boars”,
REUTERS
Divers from the rescue mission, from left to right: Chris Jewell, Mike Clayton, Rick Stanton, Lance-corporal Connor Rae, Josh Bratchley, Gary Mitchell and Jim Way who helped to save 12 schoolboys and their football coach from a flooded cave in Thailand, speak to media after arriving back at London’s Heathrow Airport
PA
Volunteers gather for a ceremony before the clean up operation at the Tham Luang cave
AFP/Getty Images
The last four Thai Navy SEALs come out safely after completing the rescue mission inside a cave where 12 boys and their soccer coach have been trapped since June 23, in Mae Sai, Chiang Rai province, northern Thailand. Thailand’s navy SEALs say all 12 boys and their soccer coach have been rescued from a flooded cave in far northern Thailand, ending an ordeal that lasted more than two weeks.
Royal Thai Navy/AP
People celebrate
AP
A woman lifts her child near the hospital, seen at left, as ambulance transporting members of the children’s football team arrives
AFP/Getty Images
Volunteers react after hearing all boys were rescued
REUTERS
REUTERS
Getty Images
Rescue personnel work at the Tham Luang cave
REUTERS
Rescue personnel work at the Tham Luang cave
REUTERS
REUTERS
Onlookers at the junction in front of Chiangrai Prachanukroh Hospital watch and cheer
Getty Images
Journalists celebrate after a news conferenc
REUTERS
An ambulance, reportedly carrying members of the rescued football team, arrives at a hospital
AFP/Getty Images
Thai Navy divers in the Tham Luang cave
Thai Navy SEAL via Getty Images
Rescue personnel work at the Tham Luang cave
REUTERS
Thai media listen Chiang Rai province acting Gov. Narongsak Osatanakorn
AP
Police and military personnel use umbrellas to cover a stretcher near a helicopter and an ambulance at a military airport in Chiang Rai as rescue operations continue for those still trapped inside the cave in Khun Nam Nang Non Forest Park in the Mae Sai district. Four boys among the group of 13 trapped in a flooded Thai cave for more than a fortnight were rescued on July 8 after surviving a treacherous escape, raising hopes elite divers would also save the others soon
AFP/Getty
Thai military medical personnel walking inside a restricted area as preparations are made to transport rescued boys from Tham Luang cave to a hospital
EPA
Thai authorities placing a rescued boy in an ambulance
EPA/Chiang Rai
Paramedics, believed to be carrying a boy who has been evacuated after being trapped inside a flooded cave, approach a helicopter in Chiang Rai
Chiang Rai Tourist Police via Reuters
This frame grab from video tweeted by Elon Musk shows a “tiny kid-sized submarine” being tested in a pool at Palisades Charter High School, in California. Musk’s Space X rocket company tested the submarine that could potentially help rescue the remaining children and their coach trapped in a flooded cave in Thailand.
Elon Musk via AP
Thai military personnel preparing to move the boys to a hospital
EPA
Emergency workers carrying one of the boys rescued from the cave
EPA/Chiang Rai
A Thai nurse walks past an ambulance at a covered area of the Chiangrai Prachanukroh Hospital
EPA
Indian schoolchildren hold placards and pictures during a prayer event for the safe rescue of young football players and their coach
AFP/Getty Images
An ambulance exits from the Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty Images
A military helicopter carrying rescued schoolboys approaches to land at a military airport in Chiang Rai.
REUTERS
A group of volunteers prepare to leave in search of alternative entry points to the Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty
Thai soldiers drag a water pipe to bypass water from the mountain and to not get back inside the cave
AP
Hundreds of rescuers with equipment continue the rescue operation
Getty
Monks lead out family members of the boys from the cave site after a morning prayer
Getty
Thai rescue workers take a break
AFP/Getty
Water pumps push water out of the cave
Getty
Relatives, of the 12 schoolboys and their soccer coach trapped inside a flooded cave in the Tham Luang cave complex cook, for rescue workers and volunteers near the cave complex
REUTERS
Rescue teams carry water pipes to the entrance of cave complex
AP
Thai soldiers and police officers are seen as rescue operations continue for the 12 boys and their football team coach trapped in Tham Luang cave at Khun Nam Nang Non Forest Park in the Mae Sai district of Chiang Rai province on July 7, 2018. More than 100 chimneys are being drilled into the mountainside in a frantic bid to reach a Thai youth football team trapped in a cave complex below, the head of the rescue mission said on July 7
AFP/Getty
Family members pray in front of a Buddhist statue near a cave where 12 boys and their soccer coach have been trapped since June 23, in Mae Sai, Chiang Rai province, in northern Thailand Saturday, July 7, 2018. The soccer coach trapped in a cave with 12 Thai boys apologized to their parents in the first letter he and the team have sent out through divers, in which the boys say they’re doing well and missing their families
AP
Thai military inside the cave complex
EPA
Australian Federal Police and Defense Force personnel talk with a Thai diver
AP
A rescuer prepares a light for diving to reach the 12 boys and their soccer coach
AP
Soliders are seen near the Tham Luang cave complex, where 12 schoolboys and their soccer coach are trapped inside a flooded cave, in the northern province of Chiang Rai, Thailand
REUTERS
Water is pumped from a flooded cave
AP
Thai rescuers rest during the ongoing rescue operation
EPA
Thai military personnel inside a cave complex
EPA
Rescue teams assemble at the entrance to the Tham Luang cave complex
AP
Thai Navy soldiers in the flooded Tham Luang cave during rescue operations
AFP/Getty
Local Thai National Park Rescuers relax at base camp
Getty Images
Journalists work near Tham Luang cave complex
REUTERS
A Thai policeman guards an area under rainfall
AFP/Getty Images
A Thai policeman guards an area under rainfall near the Tham Luang cave
AFP/Getty Images
Divers gather before they enter to the Tham Luang cave, where 12 boys and their soccer coach are trapped, in the northern province of Chiang Rai, Thailand
REUTERS
Thai military bring water pumps to the cave. Videos released by the Thai Navy SEAL shows that the boys, aged 11 to 16, and their 25-year-old coach are in good health in Tham Luang Nang Non cave and the challenge now will be to extract the party safely.
Getty Images
An honour guard holds up a picture of Samarn Kunan, 38, a former member of Thailand’s elite navy SEAL unit who died working to save 12 boys and their soccer coach trapped inside a flooded cave, at an airport in Rayong province
Reuters
Military personnel are seen in front of the Tham Luang cave
REUTERS
The former navy SEAL diver, Saman Kunan, who died trying to help save the trapped boys
Saman Kunan/Facebook
Rescue workers convene behind a large pile of oxygen tanks
AFP/Getty Images
A Buddhist monk leads military honor guards carrying a flag-draped coffin containing former Thai Navy Seal Petty Officer 1st class Saman Kunan, who died in the ongoing Tham Luang cave rescue operations, during a repatriation ceremony at Mae Fah Luang international airport.
EPA
Thai students pray for the ongoing rescue operations
EPA
Thai soldiers and police officers pay their respects as a Thai Navy plane carrying the body of Saman Kunan takes off
AFP/Getty Images
Rescue workers prepare frogsuits for soldiers
AFP/Getty Images
The diver’s death raises serious doubts over the safety of attempting to bring the 12 boys and their football coach out through the cramped, waterlogged passageways of the Tham Luang cave.
AP
Family members pray before a shrine in Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty Images
A family member prays before a shrine in Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty Images
Thai rescue teams use headlamps to enter a pitch-black cave complex where 12 boys and their soccer coach went missing, in Mae Sai, Chiang Rai province, northern Thailand, Monday, July 2, 2018. The group was discovered late July 2 after 10 days totally cut off from the outside world, and while they are for the most physically healthy, experts say the ordeal has likely taken a mental toll that could worsen the longer the situation lasts.
AP
The mother of a trapped child reacts during the ongoing rescue operations
EPA
Family members pray before a shrine in Tham Luang cave area
AFP/Getty Images
Grandmother Kham-aoey Promthep, 64, shows a photograph of her grandson, Duangpetch Promthep, who is one of 13 members
EPA
A Thai student shows an image of her classmate Panumas Sangdee, who is one of 13 members of a soccer team trapped
EPA
Buddhist monk Kruba Boonchum visits the site to perform religious rituals
Getty Images
Thai Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha visits the site
REUTERS
British cave-divers (from left to right) Richard William Stanton, Robert Charles Harper and John Volanthen join the rescue effort
AFP/Getty Images
Divers prepare for the rescue mission
EPA
A rescuer enters the cave
AP
The father of one of the missing boys thanks soldiers after the boys are found
AFP/Getty Images
Relatives celebrate after they hear that the boys have been found
AFP/Getty Images
Relatives pray after they hear that the boys have been found
Getty Images
Relatives celebrate after they hear that the boys have been found
AFP/Getty Images
General Bancha Duriyaphan announces the news to the press
Getty Images
With the rescue mission still ongoing, Thai soldiers carry equipment into the cave
EPA
With the rescue mission still ongoing, Thai soldiers carry equipment into the cave
EPA
Water is being pumped out of the flooded cave complex in an effort to make the rescue easier
Getty Images
Enraged by Mr Unsworth’s criticism, Mr Musk tweeted to his then 22.5 million followers the veteran diver was a “pedo guy”.
Although he quickly apologised for the accusation, the next month he repeated the unfounded allegation in an email to BuzzFeed.
In response to a query from a journalist at the website, Mr Musk said: “I suggest that you call people you know in Thailand, find out what’s actually going on and stop defending child rapists, you f****** a******.
“He’s an old, single white guy from England who’s been travelling to or living in Thailand for 30 to 40 years, mostly Pattaya Beach, until moving to Chiang Rai for a child bride who was about 12 years old at the time.”
It seems it was these claims which convinced the judge Mr Unsworth’s defamation suit had merit and was not simply litigating a hyperbolic insult on Twitter.
Judge Stephen Wilson ruled Mr Musk “did not call [Mr Unsworth] a ‘pedo guy’ and leave it there. Rather, he made follow-up statements indicating that he believed his statements to be true.”
The diver, who several of those involved in rescuing the Thai boys have said played a pivotal role in their successful extraction from the caves, is seeking more than $75,000 (£58,000) in damages and a court order prohibiting the Tesla CEO from making any more disparaging remarks.
Support free-thinking journalism and subscribe to Independent Minds
It is not the first time Mr Musk’s freewheeling tweets have caused the billionaire problems.
Last year he was forced by the US stock market regulator to agree to have any tweets which could affect Tesla’s stock price pre-approved by the company’s lawyers.
This settlement was imposed on Mr Musk after he caused Tesla stock to soar when he tweeted he had funding to take the company private.